Rufus Pollock

Rufus Pollock is Founder and President of Open Knowledge.

More Reading

Post navigation

7 Comments

  • Wouldn’t it be more frictionless if you seperate classification from item? E.g. providing a list of countries and their data, not a dataset containing both country and region. Or if you need to do so, at least add a variable indicating wether the data are for regions or countries. Also, in ten datasets, you use two different codes for countries. We need common standards for one concept, right? Or at least translation tables between codings.

    • @twitter-356089631:disqus good comments. Could you point out the datasets you mean (and, even better, raise issues on them – see the “report issue” on each dataset page).

      Re the country codes: would love to fix this – again please just raise an issue on the relevant dataset!

    • Crudely the differences are:

      a) OData is oriented to API support whilst the formats mentioned here say nothing about API structure but are focused on (bulk) “transport”.

      b) OData is Atom + JSON based whilst Data Package says nothing about the data structure and Simple Data Format requires CSV as the Data Structure.

      c) OData is much more detailed regarding schemas – Simple Data Format is (intentionally) very simple.

      d) OData does require a specialist library or tool to handle whilst Data Package and Simple Data Format attempt to largely build on format that are already easily processable (or degrade to such formats)

  • Good work! I tried implementing the standard, but got confused soon:
    http://data.kartverket.no/stedsnavn/GeoJSON/datapackage.json
    What is the suggested format of the “hash” field?
    Now in the assesment criteria you suddenly say that data should be CSV only. The datapackage standard talks about the simple table schema for JSON. How about GeoJSON properties?
    I submitted a few issues in the tracker. Looking forward to work on this.

    • Great points and I’ve already replied to some of them in the tracker. I note that Data Packages can transport any kind of data (including geojson) but for Simple Data Format it must be CSV.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

back to top